Given how badly Flash is getting smacked-down at the moment, I find this hilarious.
Right now, Adobe.com’s store page (where you get redirected if you google for Adobe products) doesn’t work in a mainstream desktop browser (Firefox). I go to the page, and suddenly my keyboard stops working, and the mouse is only half working. WTF?
Ah. A bit of digging, and I find crap like this:
…fully “custom” scrollbar, which I suspect is disabling keyboard and mouse input.
What does this achieve?
- HEY! It looks “different”!
- Confusing: looks like a Tab, instead of a scrollbar
- Reduces performance: this scrollbar *flickers* as you drag it, because the rendering routine is so horrendously slow. This is on a Core2 Duo processor that’s not doing anything else.
What does it break (aside from performance)?
- Keyboard navigation: spacebar, cursor keys, and left/right switch tab (VERY annoying: it seizes control of your keyboard and won’t let you navigate away)
- Mouse navigation: it bypasses the web-browser (stupid idea, Adobe), and so all the mouse gestures – even the OS-built-ins like 2-finger-scroll – stop working
It’s like a microcosm of why people get frustrated with Adobe – and perhaps of how Flash is going to go down in flames. It would be subtle and clever if today were April 1st:
- Who cares what the user thinks? Give them useless crap that doesn’t even look pretty! (think of the features added in most revisions of CS)
- …but FORCE it on them, too; choice is bad! (recall the Adobe trojan that they wrote to take over your PC and force-install Adobe products)
- Performance? Who cares about performance? (Illustrator and large files … nuff said)
3 replies on “Adobe still doesn’t understand this “world wide web” thang…”
Actually the flicker is a long-standing Firefox bug. I know a fix was made…oh…two years ago, but never got integrated.
Thanks. Either way, I’d expect them to have noticed that in testing, and cancelled it. Or implemented browser-detection. Apparently not :(
Using the 10.3 trial version of the 64-bit Flash client, thankfully there is no flickering of the scroll bar. Tho with years of Flash/PDF being the #1 cause of browser crashes which was only recently fixed by Firefox isolating plugins in their own process, as well as Flash/PDF being by far the most common attack vector even on fully updated clients, (old: PDF zero-day, PDF 80% of exploits in 2009, 48% of computers are infected) I was happy to go to the trouble of installing Firefox addon Flashblock when Adobe suspended the alpha for linux 64-bit Flash.
Luckily Linux touchpad scrolling is not captured by Flash in the 64-bit beta altho I think it might with 32-bit, but I know most Windows users are not so lucky as the Windows Synaptics driver strangely has its own unique middle-mouse scrolling that is not functional in many cases. It would be nice if browser keyboard navigation was not disabled with a Flash object in active focus, but as you say that’s why people don’t use Flash.